PickensPlan

After a person learns a certain amount, they tend to think they know enough to have the answers. It is rare and beautiful thing when you come across someone that knows that we really don't know anything and the only thing that is certain is it is more important to ask the right questions than to think you have the answer. Rest assured, if you are sure you know the answer, you are wrong.
The Pickens Plan sounds great, and I applaud the fact that he is doing something. However, I think that if you start asking questions about what you hear there is much to be desired.
What will happen if we replace >20% of our power generation capabilites with a source that we cannot control? (A gas turbine can be turned on when needed in a relatively short period of time. If the wind isn't blowing, 20% of the country is without power.)
What will the impact of using natural gas in a machine that has an average efficency of 20% (and a maximum of around 40%...automobiles) instead of a machine that averages 40% (gas turbine for electricity generation) and has already acheived 60% efficiency (combined cycle gas turbines) and has not yet reached its limit? (This seems to be contrary to the generally accepted practice of "increasing" efficiency and using resources more wisely.)
How will home utility prices be affected by replacing a cheaper source of power (natural gas) with a more expensive one (wind)? Wind is free, (technically it isn't because land owners have "wind rights" and must be paid for them) but the turbines and service contracts are not.
Why will it take so long for nuclear power to be a player? The technology is 50+ years old and relies on technology that exists today and materials that are readily available. (If you discount nuclear power because it is an unsafe, not well understood technology, consider yourself uneducated because that is not true.)
If you think the solution to the energy crisis is to use a more expensive alternative when a cheaper fuel is available (regardless of the environmental impact) you are either rich or have your head in the clouds.
If you think there is no energy crisis and this is all a government/corporate scheme to get our money, you are under-educated and should rememdy that.
The only way we will shift from fossil fuels (foreign or domestic) is to have a cheaper, as reliable, as available energy source. The way to get there is to penalize people that use energy irresponsibly (in the form of a luxury/wasted resource tax) and use the money to finance whatever improvements are necessary to make other solutions cheaper, as reliable, and as available as fossil fuels.
For example, any retailer that has an open air refrigerator should have to pay a wasted resource tax for cooling their merchandise/the air while using a heating system to keep the air inside the store warm. All that revenue can go to solar engineers to increase efficiency/reduce manufacturing costs of panels.
Any wireless device (that is not for medical use) should have a luxury tax. All the revenue generated can be given to hydrogen fuel research to replace gasoline as automobile fuel. (The technology exists today to make hydrogen for automobiles at $2/gallon and internal combustion engines can operate on hydrogen. The problem is there is not a good way to store hydrogen. That problem could more than likely be solved if funding were available. I am fully aware of the hydrogen debate but don't care. Gasoline engines weren't that great when they were put into use. Improvements are made over time after a product is introduced.)
I don't claim to know everything (or anything). I do know that being rich doesn't make you smart and being smart doesn't mean people will listen to you.
T. Boone has a plan, a lot of money, and should be challenged, not blindly followed. What good will any of this do us if his plan is flawed?

Share

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

As far as I know, the sun has been reliably rising for the past ten billion years, and that is good enough for me. I say utilize solar where practical, and wind where it is windy. Duuuuhhhhh.
And for those of you too young to remember WHY America stopped building Nuclear Power Plants in about 1980, read your old newspaper files.

And about that sun, todays solar panels charge even on a cloudy day. We get upwaards of 165 inches of rain a year, and we are NOT on the grid and we get plenty of power to run pump, lights, TVs, computer, refrigerator, etc. And it cost us total $18000 in 2007.

Reply to This

<<And for those of you too young to remember WHY America stopped building Nuclear Power Plants in about 1980, read your old newspaper files.>>

And IF you wish to find out WHY many Americans STOPPED voting for the Democratic party about that time, read about all the people that got killed by rideing in the back seat of a Democratic Senators' car. MORE civilians have died from THIS activity that all of the nuclear accidents in this country, COMBINED!!!

THINK about it!

The Deuceman

Reply to This

Wow!
Confusion, assumptions, and more questions!
The Pickens Plan makes total sense, BUT WE DON'T NEED THESE HIGH-POWERED TRANSMISSION LINES THAT LOSE LOTS OF POWER IN TRANSMITTING THE ELECTRICITY.
CLICK HERE for science/energy data and what needs to be done TO KEEP THE PICKENS PLAN GOING.

Listen to Lee Iacocca:
'Am I the only guy in this country who's fed up with what's happening? Where the hell is our outrage? We should be screaming bloody murder! We've got a gang of clueless bozos steering our ship of state right over a cliff, we've got corporate gangsters stealing us blind, and we can't even clean up after a hurricane much less build a hybrid car. But instead of getting mad, everyone sits around and nods their heads when the politicians say, 'Stay the course..' Stay the course? You've got to be kidding. This is America , not the damned, 'Titanic'. I'll give you a sound bite: 'Throw all the bums out!'


CLICK HERE for straight science/energy/solutions facts.

Reply to This

Nonsense!
To look past the "Politics as usual" El Toro Poo Poo, CLICK HERE.
Wind and Sun energy lasts forever; all we need is to harvest it!
Lee Iacocca: "Stay the course? You've got to be kidding. This is America , not the damned, 'Titanic'. I'll give you a sound bite: 'Throw all the bums out!" - - - "and they can't even build a plug-in hybrid!"

Reply to This

RSS

© 2009   Created by PickensPlan

Badges  |  Community Guidelines  | Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service